Hate ads?! Want to be able to search and filter? Day and Night mode? Subscribe for just $5 a month!

Shapiro: MN Should Charge Agents with Voluntary Manslaughter for Pretti Shooting

Listen to Article

Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro just dropped a bombshell on MSNBC’s Deadline, calling for Minnesota officials to slap Border Patrol agents with voluntary manslaughter charges over the fatal shooting of armed suspect Alex Pretti. For those late to the party, Pretti was a wanted felon who fled a traffic stop, crashed his vehicle, and then charged at agents with a realistic-looking AR-15 replica—pointed right at them—before they opened fire in self-defense. Bodycam footage backs this up crystal clear: no ambush, no excessive force, just agents doing their job against an imminent deadly threat. Yet Shapiro, ever the progressive darling, wants to criminalize their split-second decision, twisting a textbook good shoot into a prosecutable offense.

This isn’t just sloppy punditry; it’s a direct assault on the castle doctrine principles that underpin the Second Amendment. Voluntary manslaughter implies heat-of-passion killing without malice—Shapiro’s framing downplays the agents’ reasonable fear of death or great bodily harm, the exact standard that justifies deadly force for civilians too. Imagine applying this to your average 2A defender: you’re in your home, intruder bursts in waving what looks like an AR, you drop him, and suddenly DA’s like Shapiro want you in cuffs? It’s the same logic gun-grabbers use to demonize stand-your-ground laws, eroding the legal shield for self-defense nationwide. Shapiro’s rhetoric fuels the narrative that armed citizens (or agents) are the real criminals, paving the way for stricter use-of-force rules that could hamstring law enforcement and CCW holders alike.

For the 2A community, this is a flashing red light: high-profile Dems like Shapiro are mainstreaming the idea that protecting yourself with a gun is manslaughter unless you’re a helpless victim dialing 911. It amplifies calls to disarm border agents and civilians, ignoring how Pretti’s fake rifle mimicked real threats in a nation where active shooters don’t send RSVPs. Rally around this—share the footage, call out the hypocrisy (Shapiro’s fine with Philly’s Soros-backed DAs soft on actual criminals), and push back hard. If agents get charged for this, your next range day could be your last as a free man. Stay vigilant, armed, and vocal.

Share this story