Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier has issued a legal opinion holding that the state’s 2018 bump-stock prohibition is unconstitutional under the Second Amendment, a move the VSO Gun Channel host called a major win for both Florida gun owners and the broader forced-reset-trigger (FRT) movement. The opinion states the overly broad statute appears to restrict lawful trigger enhancements and that the office will no longer defend convictions under it. Hosts framed the development as Florida catching up with post-Bruen jurisprudence after years of what they described as “asinine” restrictions originally tied to former officials Pam Bondi and Rick Scott.
What the Opinion Says
Uthmeier’s office concluded that section 790.222 Florida Statutes “imposes a categorical prohibition on an entire class of firearms components that can increase a semi-automatic weapons rate of fire.” Semi-automatic firearms with such modifications are “bearable arms covered by the Second Amendment’s plain text,” and no historical tradition justifies banning them for sporting, defensive, or other lawful purposes. The host praised the AG for correctly distinguishing bump stocks and similar devices from machine guns and for applying Bruen’s burden-shifting framework.
Implications for FRTs and National Policy
- Immediate effect: Florida residents who kept FRTs or bump stocks as “status-symbol contraband” can now use them more openly; the host expects rapid mainstream adoption in a large, trend-setting state.
- Market and legal strategy: Widespread lawful use strengthens “common use” arguments (already exceeding the stun-gun numbers in Caetano) and could deter or fatally undermine any future federal attempt to redefine machine guns to include rate-enhancing devices.
- Political warning: A 2029–2030 rewrite of the NFA would invite fresh constitutional challenges from groups such as FPC, GOA, and SAF, potentially jeopardizing the Hughes Amendment itself.
The host urged officials in other states with similar bans to follow Uthmeier’s example: “If you are a politician in a state or local that has the power over ridiculous unconstitutional regulations like this, this is how you are to behave.” He added that the Florida decision “puts the next move on the chessboard” for rolling back NFA-style restrictions through both market saturation and litigation.
Host’s Assessment
“This is huge news nationally for the Second Amendment movement,” the host said. “Forced reset triggers are headed to the state of Florida. And this is a big big deal, not just for the residents of the state of Florida, but the Second Amendment movement and the FRT movement.” He predicted that any future congressional effort to lump FRTs with machine guns would ultimately backfire by creating a clean vehicle for courts to strike down the underlying 1934 framework.