Safari Club International is questioning a Los Angeles County Superior Court ruling after the Catalina Island Conservancy killed 670 mule deer in a first-phase Middle Ranch operation, more than three times the 200 animals it had forecast. Conservancy surveys in 2025 estimated about 2,040 deer across the island interior excluding Avalon. SCI and its litigation partners challenged California Department of Fish and Wildlife approval of the Catalina Island Restoration Project, saying the agency did not meet California environmental review and public participation requirements and lacked authority to authorize full eradication of an established game mammal population through a Restoration Management Permit.
The court dismissed the claims in September. SCI appealed and asked that further eradication wait until the appeal is decided, as the Conservancy has indicated additional removals will begin in mid-2027.