Concealed-carry laws over the last decade created demand for rimfire cartridges designed for compact handguns rather than rifles, and manufacturers responded.
A ballistician who tested older high-velocity .22 Long Rifle and .22 Winchester Magnum Rimfire loads in short-barreled pistols found they lagged behind standard .38 Special ammunition, though extra barrel length improved results and some magnum bullets still achieved useful penetration despite heavy muzzle flash from rifle powders.
Newer defensive loads from CCI, Federal, Winchester, Speer and Hornady apply centerfire-style expanding or solid bullets plus improved propellants. The tester would carry any of the current .22 Magnum options if limited to that caliber but continues to prefer compact centerfire pistols, observing that a small gun on hand outperforms a larger one left at home.