Op-Ed by Physician Starts with Repeating Bogus Claims About Kids and ‘Gun Violence’

May 15, 2026
4:45 pm

▶

Listen to Article

A physician's op-ed in a major outlet kicks off with the tired trope that Massachusetts—our beacon of strict gun control—suffers from rampant gun violence killing kids left and right. But hold the stethoscope: this doc recycles debunked stats, like claiming pediatric firearm deaths are skyrocketing without mentioning the CDC's own data showing most are suicides (over 50% nationally), not some urban homicide epidemic. In the Bay State, where AR-15s are banned and mags capped at 10, the actual homicide rate for under-18s hovers around 1-2 per 100,000—dwarfed by car crashes and drownings. It's a classic case of emotional sleight-of-hand: conflate all firearm deaths to demonize guns, ignoring that red states with looser laws often see lower youth suicide rates thanks to better mental health access, not disarmament. Dig deeper, and this isn't just sloppy medicine; it's advocacy masquerading as expertise. The piece pushes for more red flag laws and universal checks, yet Massachusetts already has both, plus a shall-issue permitting process that's anything but. FBI stats confirm: violent crime in gun-controlled paradises like Mass. and Cali outpaces many permissive states when adjusted for population. The implication? Physicians like this one aren't analyzing data; they're laundering anti-2A talking points through white-coat privilege, eroding public trust in real public health solutions like school hardening or addressing the mental health crisis fueling 60% of youth gun deaths. For the 2A community, this is rally-the-troops material. Call out the BS with facts—share CDC WISQARS breakdowns, Mass. DOJ crime reports, and studies like the RAND meta-analysis showing no clear link between gun laws and youth violence drops. Push back on social media, letter-to-editor campaigns, and support orgs like Giffords Law Center's own data audits (ironically, they admit the complexity). If we let MDs dictate policy without scrutiny, next it'll be gun violence cures via prescription pad. Arm yourself with truth, not hysteria—our kids deserve evidence-based safety, not emotional gun grabs.

Best FFL Software Ranked and Compared!

A physician’s op-ed in a major outlet kicks off with the tired trope that Massachusetts—our beacon of strict gun control—suffers from rampant gun violence killing kids left and right. But hold the stethoscope: this doc recycles debunked stats, like claiming pediatric firearm deaths are skyrocketing without mentioning the CDC’s own data showing most are suicides (over 50% nationally), not some urban homicide epidemic. In the Bay State, where AR-15s are banned and mags capped at 10, the actual homicide rate for under-18s hovers around 1-2 per 100,000—dwarfed by car crashes and drownings. It’s a classic case of emotional sleight-of-hand: conflate all firearm deaths to demonize guns, ignoring that red states with looser laws often see lower youth suicide rates thanks to better mental health access, not disarmament.

Dig deeper, and this isn’t just sloppy medicine; it’s advocacy masquerading as expertise. The piece pushes for more red flag laws and universal checks, yet Massachusetts already has both, plus a shall-issue permitting process that’s anything but. FBI stats confirm: violent crime in gun-controlled paradises like Mass. and Cali outpaces many permissive states when adjusted for population. The implication? Physicians like this one aren’t analyzing data; they’re laundering anti-2A talking points through white-coat privilege, eroding public trust in real public health solutions like school hardening or addressing the mental health crisis fueling 60% of youth gun deaths.

For the 2A community, this is rally-the-troops material. Call out the BS with facts—share CDC WISQARS breakdowns, Mass. DOJ crime reports, and studies like the RAND meta-analysis showing no clear link between gun laws and youth violence drops. Push back on social media, letter-to-editor campaigns, and support orgs like Giffords Law Center’s own data audits (ironically, they admit the complexity). If we let MDs dictate policy without scrutiny, next it’ll be gun violence cures via prescription pad. Arm yourself with truth, not hysteria—our kids deserve evidence-based safety, not emotional gun grabs.

Share this story