The New York Times says Justice Antonin Scalia’s Heller opinion used dangerous and unusual for a historical carrying limit, while Blackstone in 1769 used or. Since 2008 courts applied the test in at least 98 civil cases challenging weapons rules, overturning 20 including Judge Roger Benitez’s 2023 strike of California’s assault weapons ban.
After New York State Rifle and Pistol Association v. Bruen the standard became part of reviewing firearms restrictions, with 68 upholds, 20 strikes, and seven partial invalidations among those cases. Justice Clarence Thomas in Bruen answered New York, amici, and Justice Stephen Breyer’s dissent by saying the statutes only restated the common-law offense of carrying arms to terrorize people, not a ban on firearm classes.