Hate ads?! Subscribe for just $5 a month!

Eleventh Circuit Says Machine Guns Are Not Protected by the Second Amendment

Listen to Article

The Eleventh Circuit just dropped a bombshell that’s got the 2A world buzzing: machine guns aren’t covered by the Second Amendment. In a ruling tied to Maxon Alsenat’s conviction for Glock switches—those tiny devices that turn semi-auto pistols into full-auto fire machines—the court leaned hard on Justice Scalia’s Heller opinion. They argued that M-16 rifles and the like (explicitly called out as weapon[s] of war in Heller) may be okay for military use, but civilian machine guns? Not so much. It’s a classic bearable arms carve-out, where the judges twisted Scalia’s words to say these are beyond the pale for us plebs.

But let’s peel back the layers—this isn’t just legalese; it’s a stealthy expansion of the Hughes Amendment’s ghost. Remember, that 1986 ban on new civilian machine guns was never properly voted on, yet here it is, getting judicial steroids. The court dismissed Bruen’s history-and-tradition test by claiming fully automatic weapons are a modern invention post-dating the Founding era, ignoring black-powder equivalents like the Belton flintlock (offered to the Continental Congress in 1777) or even rapid-fire volley guns. Clever dodge, right? They’re essentially saying the Framers couldn’t foresee John Browning’s genius, so screw tradition. For the 2A community, this sets a dangerous precedent: if machine guns get Heller-ized out, what’s next? Suppressors? SBRs? Anything military-grade?

The implications ripple far—expect this to fuel SCOTUS petitions and state-level pushback, especially in Florida where Alsenat’s case brewed. Pro-2A warriors should rally around amicus briefs highlighting historical analogs and Bruen’s mandate to ditch interest-balancing. It’s a reminder that Heller’s presumptively lawful nod to NFA regs was never a blank check; courts are chipping away, one switch at a time. Stay vigilant, stock up on legal ammo, and keep fighting—because if we lose full-auto, the slippery slope leads straight to single-shot muskets for all.

Share this story