On November 15 around 1:06 a.m. in Cassian, Oneida County, Wisconsin, 75-year-old Marshall Robinson of Harshaw fatally shot 35-year-old James Roath of Harshaw after Roath allegedly grabbed Robinson’s glasses and tried to force his way inside. About two minutes earlier an elderly neighbor told dispatch at 1:04 a.m. that an unknown intoxicated man had entered her home; she got him outside, locked the door, and he pounded and kicked it before leaving.
Robinson armed himself after pounding on his house, opened the door with a handgun, and fired when Roath grabbed his glasses and tried to push through; crews could not save Roath at the scene. On November 17 the Oneida County Sheriff’s Office named both men, reported no arrests, and forwarded findings to the Oneida County District Attorney without saying whether the shooting was justified. The case, listed by the AmmoLand Defensive Gun Use Tracker, shows why the Second Amendment protects armed self-defense for older Americans facing younger people who had already entered another elderly resident’s home.